What would you do in this situation
Seriously, I would love to hear different perspectives here.
I am the coach of the YMCA soccer team. As a coach who has been a soccer mom/assistant coach more than half a dozen times, I made the conscious decision to run this team with all of the parents involved. It has worked out really well to this point.
We have our regular practice on Wednesday nights but the parents voted to have a second practice on Friday nights - so I am giving an extra night of coaching. I also have an amazing co-coach who joined our team at the last minute, someone who has actually played the sport.
We have one player who is naturally talented and can play every position well. He is foreign and does not seem to always comprehend what is going on though. He came to the first practice wondering why we were just passing the ball back and forth and not playing. He has missed a good number of practices and has been late to the ones he has shown up to.
At the first practice I gave all the parents a folder that I created with;
- rules about soccer game play so that they can review with their children
- photo packages for photo day
- game schedule with date, time and whether we were home or away
I also sent the link to the game schedule to every parent. I also email every parent each week the time of day of the game and the color jersey (blue for away and white for home) we are to wear. I also remind the parents of game time and jersey color on Wed AND Fri.
This talented kid, who could be a much better player if he came to practice, showed up today right on time wearing the wrong jersey. The parent made no effort to go home and change the jersey.
It was suggested that he switch jersy's with a kid on the side when he goes into play, which would have been chaotic, or that he play goalie, which would only be for one quarter because we have to play other kids in that position. I made the decision that he would have to sit out the game and cheer his team on. I think it would have been good for him as someone who needs to learn to play with a team and for his mom who needs to be more responsible. By second quarter I agreed to let him play one quarter as a goalie.
Many parents on the team got upset with me for not letting him play. My co-coach and my husband both defended my decision by explaining it is not fair to our team or the other team getting confused in the game about what team he was on. I made the point that this was a great time for the child to learn one of the fundamentals in YMCA sports - responsibility. The mom of the child claimed that she is busy. I explained that I run a business and I do not accept busy as an excuse when all she needs to do is come to practice, to the game on time with the right jersey, which I have provided EVERY communication I can think of to help them out in those areas.
One father in particular thought I was being a hard ass to a 6 year old. I explained it had nothing to do with the child, but as a parent, I myself have messed up, more than once, and I have to take the responsibility of the mistake, not expect concessions that would/could be distracting to other kids. Also, what lesson are we teaching the kids if we shrug our shoulders and always let everything be ok because they are 6 or 7. When do we show them there are consequences to their actions.
Am I being a hard ass?


