The essay below was written 7/9/98 for a college writing class. Today I was listening to a CNN report about the growing trend of moms bringing their babies to work and other people bashing working moms. I felt the need to republish this
-----------------------------
I don't know if I'll ever want to be a stay-at-home mom. When I had
to stay home for six weeks after my son, Christian, was born I felt
like a healthy, energetic, intelligent woman caught in the body of a
quarantined servant. My husband and I both waited on tables, which were
jobs flexible enough that we could begin to tag team when I finally got
back to work. We were partners in the parenting game. Little did we
know we were playing against the rules.
One day, while I was at work, my husband decided to take our son,
who was 5 months old, to the beach. We had a little raft that Christian
could sit up in, and my husband had him in the water bouncing on the
waves. A woman walked over to him and said "your wife lets you take
your baby to the beach." It was quite possible she would have reacted
in a similar fashion to me had I been the one bouncing Christian over
the waves. I just wonder if she would have phrased it in the same way,
asking me if my husband gave me such permission.
In this world where women are battling for equality in the
workplace, I hear little of the men battling for equality at home. I
have met many men who are much more active in the care of their
children than fathers historically have been, but I've not heard anyone
talk too much of the unfair treatment men receive as fathers, such as
people making the comment that my husband is babysitting when he has
our child. Babysitting?
As my son became a toddler, I wanted to find a weekly play group to
join. Since I worked half of the time, I was looking for a co-ed play
group, that way Matt and I could meet other couples that we could
relate to as well. There were no co-ed play groups. I was told that
some of the play groups had father's day when the dad's could join.
Dad's need to be invited? These were women making these rules. Women
who used to have careers, still dreamed of returning to those careers,
why would they want to bury themselves and not give their partners the
shovel?
My neighbor and I were discussing about why women had a harder
struggle to cross the gender lines than men do. She explained that if
my son wanted to take dance lessons, which we would stereotype as
feminine, he may get teased, but he would be allowed. If my neighbor
wanted to sign her daughter up for baseball, she could be told "I'm
sorry, the softball team signs up next month. Girls don't play
baseball." So maybe women have had so much held back from them in the
past that they are afraid to give up what they already have, such as
responsibility for the children.
I can understand the fear that if for
some reason my husband an I ever divorced I may lose custody, unlike
twenty years ago when men rarely got custody. But isn't there a saying
about if you hold a bird in your hand too tightly you will kill it?
What are women doing to this notion of equality by not sharing some of
the responsibilities? I know that I am not super woman who can handle
the home, the children and a career effectively on my own. Who says I
need to? Who says that if I can't do it I need to give up the career
part? Are fathers being given the chance to be more involved in
parenting? Where do we, as a society even begin to address the changing
roles of dads?
When I consider how many fathers parent, I begin to see another
reason why mothers aren't so willing to give up, or share portions of
their responsibility. Fathers make wonderful playmates, and sometimes
are efficient at disciplining. However many of the mothers I've spoken
to don't feel that the dad's handle upset children well, don't know how
to comfort. Also if a mother works, dad's who share can usually take
care of the children or clean the house, but usually not both. It is as
though women are diving into new gender roles, men are testing the
water.
I think the idea of masculinity has something to do with that. As my
neighbor said, "it seems the further away from femininity people get,
the better." According to her, this social idea is why my son would be
teased if he took dance lessons and her daughter would do fine if she
were able to play baseball. I think there is a point here. I remember a
girl and a guy in my sports marketing class talking about the sports
they played in school, and about the game they saw the previous night.
She seemed no less feminine talking about sports than if she were
talking about a great meal she made. However, when I was drawn into the
conversation, I mentioned that my husband doesn't watch sports. GASP!
Along came the smirks and comments related to maybe he hasn't come out
of the closet yet. At this point I figured it wouldn't be a good idea
to go on about how he was an interior design major and a wonderful
housekeeper.
A man who is good with structure and color would be fine as a fine
arts major, but to use his talent in a major with a bit more
income, but dominated by women, and add that he doesn't like sports,
something must be wrong. I have a feeling what went wrong was that he
was raised by a single mom and missed all the masculine influences that
would have clued him in that although the laundry needs to be done, and
your wife has fifty hours of homework to do in one night, it's not
manly to wash clothes.
I think it was my father who made me rebel against the stereotypical
woman jobs. He thought that women wanted to serve men. Wanted to! He
told me once, when he had a girlfriend move in, that he was going to
have to let go of his housekeeper because his girlfriend might get
jealous. He felt they were fighting among themselves about who would
take care of him. I think it was this attitude that made me not want to
learn how to cook or iron or sew and so on. I felt that if I learned to
do these things I would be pigeon holed as a housewife. I also never
learned how to type because I wanted to be more than a secretary. I now
realize those ideas are crazy, I guess.
Once a week, my husband and son
leave the house so I can get some work done. They don't go to the park
to play ball, they go to the laundry room. My son learns his colors and
practices his sorting skills when they are separating the darks
from the lights, and whites. He loves putting the clothes in the dryer
and thinks static is magic. They aren't doing anything special, my
husband is not babysitting, it's just a normal day together. I fear
that as we graduate and move into careers that expect me to stay home
with the sick child and won't give my husband such allowances as a
father, we will begin to play within what I've seen to be the proper
social rules for mothers and fathers.